[ Rules ] [ ot / g / m ] [ pt / snow / w ] [ meta ] [ Discord ]

/ot/ - off-topic

Name
Email
Subject
Comment
File
Youtube
Password
(For post deletion)

File: 1568202719604.jpg (128.04 KB, 600x561, aprilbracosmile[1].jpg)

No. 460616

This thread is for the discussion of transgenderism / trans ideology from a gender critical and radical feminist perspective. It was originally created by Admin as an amalgamation of the TERF and Transgender threads.

Gender critical and radical feminism define gender as sociological (feminine/masculine) and sex as biological (female/male). Woman is defined as an adult human female. Radical feminists seek to abolish gender as it is used by patriarchy to oppress women socially, reproductively, and financially. They strive to preserve women's spaces (such as restrooms, locker rooms, and health care providers) and areas of artistic and intellectual expression separate from men.

Trans ideology posits that one's gender is self-determined based on one's feelings and defines woman as the characteristics and behaviors traditionally ascribed to females by society. Increasingly, transactivists are conflating gender and sex and asserting that a person can self-identify both gender and sex.

Gender critical feminists strive to maintain the distinction between gender and sex. The conflation of gender and sex erases the biological reality of women, eliminates women-only spaces, and disestablishes women as a protected class. Existing laws and legislation currently being passed around the world allowing for self-identification on legal documents do not differentiate between gender and sex.

The acronym TERF (Trans-Exclusionary Radical Feminism) is used primarily by transactivists and their allies to denigrate radical feminists and other women who express gender critical ideas. Transactivists portray TERFs as violent oppressors by virtue of their ideas alone.

Posts of related news and web articles are welcome. Posts of photos, videos, and blogs of transactivists for the purposes of discussion and critique are welcome. Please refrain from derailing, infighting, and ad hominem attacks. This thread is not intended for the general discussion of feminism, sexuality, misogyny, or misandry.

Radical Feminism thread >>>/ot/373459

Resources
https://bannedbytrans.wordpress.com
https://www.fairplayforwomen.com | https://twitter.com/fairplaywomen
https://www.femaleerasure.com
http://www.feministcurrent.com | https://twitter.com/feministcurrent
https://feministstruggle.org
http://www.gendercriticalactioncenter.org | https://twitter.com/gendercritical_
http://www.gendercriticalactioncenter.com
https://www.genderidentitywatch.com
https://www.gendertrending.com
http://www.gettheloutuk.com | https://getthelout.wordpress.com/blog
https://www.lesbian-rights-nz.org/shame-receipts
https://www.mayday4women.com
http://www.peaktrans.org
https://radfem.writeas.com
https://resistersunited.org | https://twitter.com/resistersu
https://www.sexandgenderintro.com
https://www.standingforwomen.com
http://www.terfisaslur.com
https://theterfexhibit.com (404) | https://www.facebook.com/TheTerfExhibit/
https://www.transgenderreality.com
https://wlrnmedia.wordpress.com
https://womenarehuman.com
https://womanmeanssomething.com
https://www.womansplaceuk.org | https://twitter.com/womans_place_uk
https://www.womensdeclaration.com
http://womensliberationfront.org
https://www.xxamazons.org
http://www.4thwavefeminists.com (404)

Blogs, Writers
https://culturallyboundgender.wordpress.com
http://gendercritical.blogspot.com
https://gendertrender.wordpress.com (suspended) | https://www.gendertrending.com
https://janeclarejones.com
https://lilymaynard.wordpress.com (suspended) | http://www.lilymaynard.com
https://thewitchofwentworth.tumblr.com
https://trannosphere.tumblr.com

Inauthentic Selves: The modern LGBTQ+ Movement Is Run By Philanthropic Astroturf And Based On Junk Science
https://medium.com/@sue.donym1984/inauthentic-selves-the-modern-lgbtq-movement-is-run-by-philanthropic-astroturf-and-based-on-junk-d08eb6aa1a4b

Forums
http://www.genderhammer.com

reddit
https://www.reddit.com/r/FinnishGenderCritical
https://www.reddit.com/r/Gender_Critical
https://www.reddit.com/r/GenderCritical
https://www.reddit.com/r/GCdebatesQT
https://www.reddit.com/r/gc_woc
https://www.reddit.com/r/LGBDropTheT

Detransitioning
https://www.reddit.com/r/detrans
https://www.peaktrans.org/detransitioning
http://sexchangeregret.com
https://www.transgendertrend.com/detransition
Pique Resilience Project
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmGEMjyAwk6R1lTmG_JjLUA
https://www.piqueresproject.com

Documenting violent crimes committed by transgender individuals
This Never Happens
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1722756661380462
https://www.reddit.com/r/thisneverhappens
https://www.peaktrans.org/crime
http://www.transcrimeuk.com

Parents and clinicians concerned about transgender youth
https://www.4thwavenow.com | https://twitter.com/4th_WaveNow
http://www.gdworkinggroup.org
https://www.gendercriticalresources.com/Support/index.php
https://www.kelseycoalition.org
https://www.parentsofrogdkids.com
http://thejungsoul.com/guidance-for-parents-of-teens-with-rapid-onset-gender-dysphoria
https://www.transgenderreality.com/about
https://www.transgendertrend.com | https://twitter.com/transgendertrd

YouTube Channels
Venice Allan
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdOAL2_mpBKEW4YO4YAPNIA/featured | http://wwwdrradfem.org
Elly Arrow
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCWlLdZ24IfDIPxth02Nt8Xg
BabyradfemTV
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCHH8wS-Kd1wUvlvrrCmMMPQ
Magdalen Berns
https://www.youtube.com/c/MagdalenBerns
Cathy Brennan / Ally Missandry
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcOhi9MQDYOhodqxi81BZkA
Dr. RadFem
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdOAL2_mpBKEW4YO4YAPNIA
KORADFEM Radical feminism in Korea
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKfFGy1tlhww6jaKtOkCe2w
https://twitter.com/boroja8902
Tanith Lloyd
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsHSFSO9tAbpKb8YE2lz7FQ
Julia Long
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXTBdgGyMFXMnM3g-tUPnIA
Meghan Murphy
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCq-04S1vzWPy3G8omi0wVvA
https://meghanmurphylawsuit.com
Peachyoghurt
https://www.youtube.com/user/Perzikyoghurt
Posie Parker
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCB7daUkou5C7zJvbBvgU8eA
https://www.theposieparker.com
A Woman's Place
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCzFqsUqDzyXEQMJVy42NwUw

Agitprop, Art, Comics, Memes
Feminist Heretic
https://www.facebook.com/feministheretic
https://feministheretic.wordpress.com
Feminist Struggle
https://feministstruggle.org/2019/05/18/dont-disappear-the-l-campaign
Nina Paley / Mimi and Eunice
http://mimiandeunice.com/category/jenndra-identitty
Red Katherinee
http://vk.com/momokotyan
https://www.instagram.com/red.katherinee
https://twitter.com/rredpeach
ReSisters
https://twitter.com/ResistersUK
Sandy Draws Badly
https://twitter.com/sandydrawsbadly
The Snowflake Books
http://www.lilymaynard.com/the-snowflake-books
The Untameable Shrews
https://www.theuntameableshrews.com
https://www.instagram.com/untameableshrews
VioletDioxazine
https://violetdioxazine.tumblr.com
Woman Adult Human Female
https://www.standingforwomen.com

Previous threads
>>>/ot/221232 01
>>>/ot/231926 02
>>>/ot/248302 03
>>>/ot/267773 04
>>>/ot/281458 05
>>>/ot/296475 06
>>>/ot/312419 07
>>>/ot/320422 08
>>>/ot/331248 09
>>>/ot/341517 10
>>>/ot/351615 11
>>>/ot/360163 12
>>>/ot/377370 13
>>>/ot/387259 14
>>>/ot/396926 15
>>>/ot/408612 16
>>>/ot/418616 17
>>>/ot/429238 18
>>>/ot/441471 19
>>>/ot/448777 20
>>454392 21

"TERF" thread >>>/g/67378
"Transpassing" thread >>>/ot/214811
"Trans women" thread >>>/ot/203215
"Crazy trans lesbians?" thread >>>/ot/116018
"I hate the way this website treats Trans* issues" thread >>>/ot/113748

No. 460621

>>460616

Did you miss Admin's announcement? We are no longer allowed to have a GC-only thread.

I am the usual OP and had the updated OP for #22 ready when she made her announcement. I asked in the last thread if the OP needs to be rewritten to be Feminism General.

No. 460626

>>460621
What? When did that happen?

No. 460628

File: 1568204787985.png (29.54 KB, 734x147, 1568104948729.png)

>>>/meta/11242

>>>/meta/11245

>>>/ot/460198

I wanted to get input from other anons about rewriting the OP, but the thread filled up with a debate on sex work instead.

No. 460630

>>460628
Sooo, we are radfem now? I mean, radfems sure are GC but GC is not necessary radfem, this seems like it is forcing a particular point of view on us.

No. 460634

>>460630

That was my exact point in >>>/meta/11245.

No. 460636

>>460635
I don't even know who that is. Why would it be funny?

No. 460637

>>460616

And OP pic is not funny nor appropriate for whatever the fuck this thread is about now.

No. 460639

>>460636

Yesterday an anon was posting Braco pics in every /ot/ thread and created a Braco thread with the same pic.

No. 460641

>>460630
There's a big difference since RF thread gets into way more academic discussion while GC focuses on laughing/cringing/screaming at troons.

No. 460642

>>460628
This is actually so retarded why? This will just create derails. And this bitch really said “problematic” lmao this is libfem conspiracy!!

No. 460643

>>460641

According to Admin it all goes here now, so I need to rewrite the OP.

No. 460645

>>460641
This is certainly an extra issue. So I can't post GC opinions if they are not radfem here? Do I have to agree with radfem to laugh at troons now?

No. 460646

>>460621
>Feminism General
But there's dozens of different branches of feminism? Are we going to have lipstick feminism in the same thread as ecofeminism and radical feminism? That's gonna be a mess.

No. 460648

>>460646
It's not even feminism general, which would be bad enough (not that I have an issue with feminism, just its forced inclusion in GC), but radfem in particular. It creates the concept of radfem and GC being linked and even one and the same, that is ludicrous!

No. 460649

>>460628
Dumbass question, but why ARENT we allowed to discuss politics in /ot? I get that it can cause arguments, but isn’t that kinda just life? Even when just laughing at trannies anons often argue with each other

No. 460651

>>460648
>being linked
They are linked though. GC originated from radical feminism.

No. 460652

>>460651
Gender critical as a philosophy sure, I was talking about gender critical the general, which is very much its own thing. I liked our little culture here. I also liked the rad fem general, mixing them up will ruin them both.

No. 460653

>>460649
There should just be a politics general, it would solve everything and if anons wanted to talk about politics they could go there.

No. 460655

>>460646
Imagine if we had libfems screaming about everyone being transphobic in the thread

No. 460656

Admin's reason for locking the RF thread:

>>>/meta/11246

>It attracts too much political infighting on the board overall.

>I took the advice of your own moderators for those threads so this isn't my sole decision.

A thread that was created six months ago at the request of anons who attended the town hall and which has been so slow most anons probably didn't even know it existed is somehow responsible for attracting infighting all over the board.

No. 460659

>>460656
>Radical feminism is political
Ya don't say?

No. 460664

>>460656
There was radical feminist discussion and sympathising with radfems on this site long before that thread was created. A lot of women weren't even really involved in feminist activism, I think they were just getting sick of troons or mainstream feminism.

No. 460667

>>460656
It’s allowed to have Kpop Crit, Kpop Gen and a damn Kpop dump thread. But can’t have separate threads for distinct political
discussions on grounds of being “problematic”. They are literally blaming political infighting on existence of political threads, instead of you know, simply that the user base itself has brains and opinions with which they use to agree or disagree with one another. Is this the ~radfem solution~ Admin been brewing up??
Lolcow truly wants to be a spineless nonoffending hive mind that women spaces are allowed to be.

No. 460669

I'm so frustrated and need to vent. My local lesbian club just closed.

I joined it about three years ago, and it was a great weekly club where local lesbians (and some bi women) got together and watched movies or went to cooking classes or just hit the nearest bar and had a drink. Great way to meet new friends, and I loved finding so many local gay women.

About a year ago a TiM joined. It was just one TiM and he was on HRT and made some attempt to pass, so although it wasn't ideal I kept going, because other than him the club was still fun. Then he brought a friend, another TiM. And then more friends. And it got to the point the club was 50% men in dresses.

They started talking over the actual women in the club, saying they didn't want to watch movies or go to particular clubs, and accusing the club leaders of transphobia when they weren't allowed to basically demand what we did each week. They always wanted to do spa visits (and since we usually pay our own way for things like that it was expensive) or do make-overs on each other like we were all suddenly 12 and having a sleepover. A bunch of women in the club don't even wear make-up.

More and more real women started to just drift away and stop attending, and I started doing the same. I'm still on the club newsletter though, but I haven't been to a meeting like 4 months. Just got the news the club is officially ending because of "lack of participation." In other words, TiMs infested it and killed it.

Why can't lesbians have anything?

No. 460676

>>460669
All lesbian events are infested with troons. Even gynecology has to be inclusive of troons now.

No. 460677

>>460652

As did I. I've been active in this thread since the beginning and value the community we have created. I come here to share and commiserate with anons who are on the same page about GC, not endlessly debate sex work and other topics.

>>460664
>>460667

Apparently now this thread is supposed to serve as a containment thread for all feminist discussion and debate because talking about feminism is icky or something.

No. 460684

File: 1568208974183.jpeg (28.22 KB, 500x376, September-01-2011-22-24-52-tum…)

>>460676
Have any obgyns had any troons come visit them yet? What would go on? Even if he did have his penis cut off and replaced by a hunk of tissue poorly sculpted into whatever labia he obsessed over most in his porn addled brain, what the fuck does the gynecologist have to even do with that? I imagine a nurse can address wound care. Do they just sit quietly?

No. 460685

>Apparently now this thread is supposed to serve as a containment thread for all feminist discussion and debate because talking about feminism is icky or something.
Greetings from /leftypol/

If it makes you feel any better the wind has been taken out of the trans sails too, I'd imagine that some democratic party strategist has realised that the identity politics coalition strategy is a losing one against trump

No. 460686

>>460684
I remember a post on /pol/ (yes I know) about one who had a troon come with "cervical cancer". It apparently had gotten cancer in the part of its genitals that were grounded into the meat that made the inside of its vagina. He did what he could, but there was so much necrosis and sepsis, that his whole team basically gave up and the troon died.

No. 460689

maybe we should colonize c.c

No. 460690

>Apparently now this thread is supposed to serve as a containment thread for all feminist discussion and debate because talking about feminism is icky or something
I didn't say that but enjoy strawmanning.

Have an issue with me sugar coating things and calling it "problematic"? Well, insufferable is a more fitting word. If you have an issue with it go to /meta/. Pink-pill is still around and the radfem thread was really about how much of a radfem nobody is.

Oh and have fun with the conspiracies while you're at it!

No. 460693

>>460686
I believe it! What levels of delusion.

>>460689
I read here it was infested with transes.

No. 460694

File: 1568209662238.png (33.6 KB, 635x353, 79878.PNG)


No. 460695

>>460690

You did say RF discussion belongs in this thread which makes this thread the RF thread, does it not? And the motivation behind this decision is eliminating political infighting elsewhere on the board, correct?

No. 460697

>>460695
> Please post in gender critical instead for the time being.

This is not a permanent solution to cutting down politics.

No. 460698

>>460690
With all due respect, radical feminsm and gender critical are not the same thing. Please reconsider, it will completely change the culture and expectations here.

No. 460699

>>460693
so? there's probably more people that post in these threads than the whole site, it's pretty dead now

No. 460701

>>460698
the OP of these threads seems to think so. they need a clear cut. i don't give a shit about any radfem politics, i just am not a science denier.

No. 460703

>>460694
Yes this is about the letter going out from NHS or something to remind them of their pap tests. Dispicable. I remember there were tweets from troons laughing about it.
That's what I mean, this is bananas.

No. 460706

>>460703
What these retards don't understand is they still have a prostate and are not called for that check up, but they still laugh about being treated as real women uwu. When they get cancer that could have easily been prevented they won't be so happy.

No. 460707

>>460701
I even agree with rad fem on a lot of things and don't like this merge. I want different places to post about gender roles being bullshit and another one to laugh at troons.

No. 460708

>>460698

This. Look at what happened to the end of the last thread. Anons don't come to the GC thread to debate sex work and child labor.

>>460701

What?

>This thread is not intended for the general discussion of feminism, sexuality, misogyny, or misandry.

No. 460709

>>460708
sorry, that's what i meant, that the OP thinks so too. my bad.

No. 460712

>>460709

NP, anon!

No. 460715

>>460697

If this decision stands even temporarily, the OP needs to be edited to reflect that.

And Braco needs to BTFO.

No. 460716

>>460708
>This. Look at what happened to the end of the last thread. Anons don't come to the GC thread to debate sex work and child labor.
You know /leftypol/'s gender and race thread could do with some mature hands
https://bunkerchan.xyz/leftypol/res/15551.html
Right now it's incels and trans having a shitfight about who's the bigger victim

No. 460717

god these threads (pink pill and radfem) are cancerous.

just fuck off somewhere else. I can't even go on /ot/ without someone sperging about how they hate men.

No. 460720

>>460717
>Implying there is anything whatsoever wrong with that

No. 460721

>>460717
i agree, i'm really sick of these spergs. you can't even have a conversation anymore about anything.

No. 460722

>>460720
no one cares how much you hate men, but still seek the validation of men everywhere Sarah

No. 460726

>>460722
Men the class and men the individual are different things. Not that men the individuals are not typically terrible and need to prove themselves not being trash before I decide to devote any amount of time or effort on them. I do the opposite of seeking validation from them, they do from me.

No. 460727

>>460726
go back to reddit faggot

No. 460729

>>460727
>go back to reddit faggot
>Realizing who your oppresors are is reddit
cute, did you come from Kotakuinaction?

No. 460730

>>460726
men are not a class you idiot.

No. 460734

>>460729
not everyone who disagrees with you is a nazi you apple titted cum smear

No. 460736

>>460717

Try C.C. Your type is more comfortable there.

No. 460737

>>460736
how many more threads does admin have to merge before you see that manhate/radfems are what isn't desirable here.

No. 460739

>>460737
You should go to C.C.

No. 460740

>>460669
I wonder if they even notice?? Like are they too stupid to notice that actual women just go away and they're left with each other?

No. 460742

>>460739
if everyone other than the radfem/pinkpillers including admin should "go to c.c" don't you think that something is amiss?

No. 460743

>>460730
Yes they are moron though I agree I just wanna laugh at troons here and not read people's idiotic fights over radfem theory get a fucking tumblr blogs if you want to do that

No. 460744

Don't respond to the scrot bait, anons. You can tell it's our usual scrot because he still hasn't learned how to sage. Just report and move on, he gets off on you guys insulting him.

No. 460746

File: 1568212949821.jpg (14.14 KB, 700x700, 40379792_986755783629524_26654…)


No. 460747

I get it half of you are probably ex-aidens and cg libfems and you learned how to interact with people through tumblr's fucked up political space but could you autists please, please learn away from the libfem identity and purity politics? I'm probably the biggest manhater here, I had to stop avoid pink pill threads because they made me rage too hard, but here's the thing: Sometimes you can shut the fuck up about it! You can have other interests and talk about something else than politics and drag it into everything. Sometimes you just wanna laugh at troons and have some light gender conversation about it without bunch of spergs fucking up the thread about in fighting abut prostitution

Go back to tumblr

No. 460748

>>460744

Tinfoil, but the timing of the last thread being overrun by a debate about SW right after the RF thread was closed and now this thread devolving into infighting is awfully convenient.

No. 460749

I'm so confused. Was PP thread nuked too?

Can RadFem and PP thread be combined and leave gc so the conservatives aren't triggered?

No. 460750

>>460747
we can't have any light conversation on /ot/ anymore. everyone is too hateful now. even the dramu boards, which are about making fun of people aren't this fucking salty all the time. and it seems everyone's opinions are so polarized and you get called a handmaiden/scrote or radfem/manhater for having any opinion that's not extreme. i think that imageboards are poison for some people, especially people who likely have little going on in their lives. and those people are poisoning the rest of the site.

No. 460753

>>460749
>not caring about radfem shit means you're conservative

please, anon.

No. 460756

>>460753
Well whatever.
Do you not see the point?

No. 460761

Let's get back on topic, I want to laugh at troons.

Has anyone else noticed how many of them are beggars or grifters? I get lots of GoFundMes retweeted on to my Twitter timeline and I've started to play a little game where I click on the bio of the person who linked their GoFundMe. It's always a troon, 10/10 times. And usually the GoFundMe page itself starts with the same spiel "I'm a poor mentally ill transgender demisexual disabled octopuskin uwu…"

No. 460762

>>460749

GC is not RF, and RF is not PP.

And the PP thread is still open.

No. 460763

>>460761

But arguing over feminism is on topic now, anon.

No. 460765

Someone pls post an ugly tranny for me to laugh at, cackling at their delusions and widows peaks is what brings me joy

I’d fall under radfem but I really don’t want heavy shit clogging up the thread that always guaranteed a laugh, why are these two being mixed - I don’t know about you anons but surely discussing the disgusting and violent behaviours of men and radfem go more hand in hand than being horrified at inverted cocks, why wasn’t radfem put in pink pill

No. 460766

File: 1568214923915.jpg (67.86 KB, 640x960, 1558312628576.jpg)

>>460765
here you go anon

No. 460767

File: 1568214985389.jpg (72.54 KB, 652x700, 1555273237728.jpg)

>>460765
just dumping some classics to calm everyone down.

No. 460768

>>460765
Sorting Reddit's Transpassing sub by controversial is my favorite source of prime tranny cringe.

No. 460769

>>460628
Why the fuck was the board locked to begin with it was barely even active, theres been like 50 posts in the last 2 weeks how is it so 'problematic' lmao.

No. 460770

File: 1568215026633.png (981.81 KB, 1250x700, 1559073175883.png)


No. 460771

>>460761
I think it might be their misogynistic belief of women getting things free in life, so because they’re ‘cute girls’ now they’re entitled to handouts

I knew a troon who always demanded that his meals be paid for and he got the return customer stamps during the weekly restaurant get together, fucking awful - the worst part was that people went along with it! Even when he admitted that the reason he couldn’t afford it because he bought himself lingerie or some other fetish shit!

No. 460772

After serious consideration, the Admin and mod team have decided to move GC threads to the Pink Pill. Discussion of gender issues will go there from now on.

>>>/ot/456390



Delete Post [ ]
[Return] [Catalog]
[ Rules ] [ ot / g / m ] [ pt / snow / w ] [ meta ] [ Discord ]