It's a cute boy thread, if you think a guy is just 'normal' but are attracted to him anyway you would know it's not what the thread is about…
I don't actually think that's what's happening here though. I'd bet anons mostly consider who they post to be incredibly cute and aren't thinking 'he's average but I like it'. But most of the more normal looking guys are celebrities who fans love for a combination of reasons other than their looks. Charisma, talent, personality, characters they play, etc can really inflate your opinion of someone's looks to the point where you can't be objective about how cute they are. Just for an example, I didn't post >>66662
but I am a figure skating fan. To a lot of girls he's probably just an average looking asian dude cause it's not like he's a model or anything, but someone who has watched him doing beautiful choreography and be an amazing athlete and so on will probably be way more attracted to him.